Orthodoxy Criticized

Critique and counter-critique is one of the hallmarks of a scholarly attitude, so it goes without saying that revisionists are taking their opponents’ arguments and responses seriously. Hence, this section addresses the theses of several orthodox scholars on the Holocaust which have evoked revisionist responses. Although most orthodox scholars insist that revisionist arguments are not even worth looking at, a number of them have in fact breached the taboo and have not only looked at revisionist arguments, but have actually deigned to criticize them in one way or other. The revisionist responses and rebuttals can be found here as well.



Documents in this category

Author Document Language Published
Rudolf, G. "Scientists" at Work English 2003-11-01
Merlin, D. The Smithsonian Institution's Documentary “Treblinka: Hitler’s Killing Machine” English 2014-06-11
Grubach, P. A Holocaust Revisionist Response to Pope Francis’s claim that “Holocaust Denial is madness”, Did the Papacy Violate Christian Ethics on the Issue of “Holocaust Denial”? English 2014-06-14
Smith, B. Smith Flies to Washington D.C. to Tour the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum English 1993-08-01
Smith, B. Smith and Smith on the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum English 1997-05-01
Smith, B. CODOH Prepares to Hang High the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum, – From Its Own "Gas Chamber" Door English 1997-09-01
Smith, B. Codoh Exposes Auschwitz Perjurer, Leading Survivor + Top Zionist Helped Found U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum English 1997-10-01
Merlin, D. "Irving v. Lipstadt" Trial for Movie Theaters, Part I English 2015-09-08
Merlin, D. "Irving v. Lipstadt" Trial for Movie Theaters, Part II English 2015-10-10
Smith, B. Holocaust Museums Come under Attack from Washington to Berlin English 1998-03-01
Widmann, R. Internet Roundup, Allied Wartime Atrocities English 1998-07-01
Smith, B. U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum Fakes Famous Niemoeller Quote English 1998-12-01
Merlin, D. "Irving v. Lipstadt" Trial for Movie Theaters, Part III English 2015-10-10
Smith, B. CODOH Takes Aim at the Ivy League with a Blockbuster Debunking of the Holocaust Museum, CODOH “Smart Bomb” Targets ADL, Wiesel too English 1999-01-01
Smith, B. CODOH vs. the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum English 1999-01-01
Smith, B. The U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum Fakes a Photo to Rake in Funds English 1999-03-01
Merlin, D. The History Channel Re-runs Hitler's Killing Machine, As a dog returns to its vomit, so fools repeat their folly English 2015-11-03
Hankins, M. Holocaust Revisionist Manipulates the Media English 1999-12-03
Cormier, R. Holocaust Revisionist Manipulates the Media English 1999-12-03
Rucker, J. USHMM Does Revisionism – VERY Cautiously English 2013-07-19
Merlin, D. Anne Frank and the New York Times English 2013-11-08
Merlin, D. Letter to the New York Review of Books English 2013-12-13
Bartesch, H. Copying Heinz Bartesch’s letter to Peter Black, Senior Historian at USHMM English 2012-04-10
Potts, N. FGCU Professor Is a Holocaust Hatchet Man English 2014-08-15
Kues, T. Comments on Treblinka Statements by Caroline Sturdy Colls English 2012-01-27
Vrij Historisch Onderzoek Kandidaten für den Cremonini-Preis German 1997-04-01
Gauss, E. Revisionistischer Funktionalismus mit höchsten jüdischen Weihen, Bücherschau German 1997-04-01
Tamo , K. The Holocaust by Bullets, Book Review English 2016-03-14
Merlin, D. Dishonest Journalist of the Week Award English 2012-01-01
Mattogno, C. Auschwitz Lies, Legends, Lies, and Prejudices on the Holocaust English 2011-07-01
Rudolf, G. Auschwitz Lies, Legends, Lies, and Prejudices on the Holocaust English 2011-07-01
Raico, R. The Taboo against Truth, Holocausts and the Historians English 1989-09-01
Mattogno, C. Brief Note on “The Central Database of Shoah Victims’ Names” and the Number of Dead Reported therein English 2013-11-20
Mattogno, C. Breve nota su “The Central Database of Shoah Victims’ Names” e il numero dei morti ivi riportati Italian 2013-11-20
Boisdefeu, J. Gassed at Treblinka and deceased in Minsk English 2006-03-01
Boisdefeu, J. Gazé à Treblinka et mort à Minsk French 2006-03-01
Olodogma How to Increase the Number of Deaths in the Holocaust English 2013-11-16
Olodogma Come aumentare il numero dei morti nell'olocausto, La moltiplicazione via web Italian 2013-11-16
Olodogma “Magda Goebbels”… nel database dello Yad Vashem Italian 2015-03-19
Boisdefeu, J. The Bankruptcy of Yad Vashem or How to Reach 6,000,000 English 2005-03-01

Series in this category