In Russia, Proposed Law Would Criminalize 'Holocaust Denial'

In Russia, Proposed Law Would Criminalize 'Holocaust Denial'

The Russian lower house has received a new bill suggesting up to five years in prison for publicly denying the Holocaust (see

Typically the law and the media reports conflate historic discussion with "inciting hatred or humiliation of human dignity" – just look at the image (right) used to illustrate this news item in the Russian media. What does historical discussion have to do with provocative postures of rambunctious youngsters?

The amendments would punish such crimes with fines ranging from 100,000 to 300,000 rubles (from $3,300 to $10,000), correctional labor for up to two years or, in severe cases, prison terms of up to two years. If the crime is committed through abuse of office or together with threats of violence, the fines are raised to 500,000 rubles (under $17,000) and a maximum prison term of five years.

The sponsor of the new censorship bill is Boris Shpigel (Spiegel, pronounce Shpigle, is German for mirror), who was leader of a group called ”World without Nazism.” Shpigel styles himself as a defender of "rights." Sure... throw historians in jail for not agreeing with your views of history. Shpigel has reacted to criticism of his advocacy of "correctional labor" for errant historians by.... guess what? Yes, calling anyone an "anti-Semite" who doesn't agree with him. Scouring mountains of negative comments, Shpigel did find a few comments that were either ugly or too pro-Palestinian. For example a sign stating "Stop the Palestine Holocaust" was allegedly proof of an "Anti-Jewish protest." (See

Shpigel's seems to have a very restricted view of free speech... granting it only to his own views.

CODOH says: Let Shpigel look into a mirror to see the ugly face of bigotry and censorship. Defend free speech!

Leave a comment