| |

Thou Shalt Not Laugh (at Schindler’s List)

By Bradley R. Smith ∙ February 1, 1995

Last updated on

The Joe Bob Report (PO Box 2002, Dallas TX 75221, $3 for a sample copy), a newsletter dedicated to the conservation of a threatened American cultural institution, the drive-in movie theater, ran an interesting article about the high school kids in Oakland who were taken to see Schindler's List and laughed at all the wrong places.

The adults “kicked out the whole crowd of sixty students from Castlemont High School, who were there on a field trip to learn about… well… about acceptance.

“… I'd like to say there is no such thing as an inappropriate response… to a movie. In other words, the audience can't be wrong. If the audience laughs, it's funny, by definition. If the audience cries, it's sad. You can't go around yanking people out of their chairs and saying, 'You can't stay at this movie, because you don't get it!'”

“These students were watching in a group. Groups are different. Groups have an energy based on what the various members of the group are doing — not what's on the screen. All the adults that got so upset were watching the movie in isolation. The high school students were watching it together. They knew who was laughing and who wasn't. After a while, it's contagious because of things that have nothing to do with the movie.”

And he adds: “I'm surprised I have to explain these things.”

  • Bradley R. Smith

    Bradley R. Smith was born in Los Angeles on February 18, 1930. At 18 he joined the army and in 1951 served with the infantry in Korea where he was twice wounded. After three decades of a variety of professional activities, it suddenly hit him: In 1979 he read a leaflet by Professor Robert Faurisson, "The Problem of the Gas Chambers." Then, Arthur Butz’s The Hoax of the Twentieth Century did it for him. He understood from the beginning that he would address the censorship, the suppression of independent thought, the taboo against publishing and debating revisionist arguments—not the arguments themselves. That has remained his position. In 1989, Smith founded Committee for Open Debate on the Holocaust (CODOH) dedicated to defending free speech and free inquiry into the Holocaust question. He handed over CODOH's helm in late 2014. He passed away on his 86th birthday, February 18, 2016. Read a series of obituaries here.

Bibliographic information about this document: Smith's Report, no. 20, February 1995, pp. 3f.taboo
Other contributors to this document: n/a
Editor’s comments: n/a

Similar Posts

  • The Taboo against Truth

    “Speaking truth to power” is not easy when you support that power. Perhaps this is the reason why so few Western historians are willing to tell the whole truth about state crimes during this century. Last fall [1988 —Ed.] the Moscow News reported the discovery by two archaeologist-historians of mass graves at Kuropaty, near Minsk,…

  • Smith — in Russian?

    There's no stopping me and CODOH. In issue 19 of SR I revealed to the public the newly formed, insidious and dangerous Zhirinovsky / Smith Axis. Z and I may well do what the might of the entire Nazi Empire failed to do — conquer Russia. The cat's out of the bag on this one…

  • The Death Mill of Blowing Rock

    Where, oh where, is Caroline Sturdy Colls when one needs her? I visited Blowing Rock, North Carolina recently and hiked a lovely trail whose head was located almost “downtown” in this mountain tourist venue. The trail followed a babbling brook called New Years Creek through the forest that surrounds the town. And as I trudged…

  • Letters to the Editor

    True and Important The “Holocaust” story is both true and important. However — The part that's true (Jewish suffering during WW II) isn't important (millions more suffered, many suffered more); The part that's important (mass genocide in “gas chambers”) isn't true. — H.N. (W. D.C.) Needed: More Libertarians I wish we could reach more libertarians…

  • How to Sabotage a Newsgroup

    Observations on verbal violence and the Usenet newsgroup alt.revisionism, with hints for potential participants Violence in speech does lead to violent action, as witnessed by the recent death of Yitzhak Rabin and its lengthy, ugly prelude of verbal excoriation of the basest sort. Yet many are those who rabidly maintain that the moral content of…

  • What Would Happen If …

    The following is an imagined memorandum or e-mail from the colleague of a Harvard University professor who, in an undergraduate history class, stated a “sensitive” historical fact concerning the Holocaust. No professor at any American university is known to have done any such thing in any such setting, nor would it seem at this time…